CasesInsightsAboutCareersAll services →Contact
NLEN
All insights

Backlinks from link directories: why they hurt your SEO and what to do instead

Handen typen op een laptop met grafieken uit Google Search Console op het scherm
Jump to7 sections

Backlinks from link directory pages seem convenient, but can seriously harm your SEO. Discover why they are risky and which backlinks are valuable in 2025.

Backlinks are a crucial part of SEO, but not every link is a good link. Link directory pages (known in the Netherlands as 'startpagina's') and link dumps seem like a quick fix, but can actually undermine your rankings. In this blog, we explain why backlinks from these pages are often harmful, what search engines like Google say about them and what you can do instead.

Why this matters

Whereas backlinks were once about quantity, in 2025 SEO is entirely about quality. Directory links may seem harmless or even smart, but they can hurt your website more than they help. Understanding why prevents unnecessary risks and wasted investments.

What you need to know about directory backlinks

Link directory pages contain little to no content of their own and mainly consist of long lists of external links. They are often:

  • Generic and without context
  • Easy (and usually paid) to obtain
  • Aimed at SEO manipulation rather than user value

Google now recognises these kinds of link strategies flawlessly and downgrades them as unnatural or spammy. Such links fall under what Google calls "link schemes": attempts to artificially influence rankings.

The risks of low-quality links

Backlinks from directory pages carry multiple risks. Examples from our SEO audits at TNG Agency show that companies often do not even know they are paying for them through dubious agencies. The consequences can be significant:

  • Ranking loss: positions in search results drop as a result of unreliable links.
  • Manual penalties: Google can penalise your website with a manual action.
  • Loss of link value: the algorithm ignores bad links, so your efforts have no effect.
  • Reputational damage: backlinks from spammy sources can reflect negatively on your brand.
  • De-indexing: in serious cases, (part of) your site can disappear from the search index.

Even without direct sanctions, directory links rarely deliver measurable SEO benefits.

What does work: characteristics of strong backlinks

A quality backlink does more than just increase your domain authority. It is a genuine recommendation, embedded in context. We recommend choosing this type of backlink:

  • Relevance: the link appears in a substantive article that fits your industry or niche. The link also genuinely explains something about your company or product.
  • Authority: the link comes from a trustworthy source, such as trade media, news media or industry platforms.
  • Few outgoing links: the value of the link is not diluted by dozens of other (external) links on the same page.
  • Added value: the link can also generate direct traffic or brand awareness.

These kinds of backlinks not only build your SEO, but also strengthen your brand and authority within your field.

Best practices for a sustainable backlink profile

Want to build a strong, future-proof backlink profile? Then follow these guidelines:

  1. Avoid bulk listings on link directory pages or directories.
  2. Use PR and content marketing to earn natural links.
  3. Publish guest blogs on relevant sites within your niche.
  4. Work on mentions in trustworthy local or industry-specific platforms. Possibly paid, but always with a focus on quality.
  5. Monitor your backlink profile regularly with tools such as Ahrefs, SEMrush or Google Search Console.

That way, you avoid risks and optimise your SEO results in the long term.

Choose quality over quantity

Directory backlinks may be cheap and easy, but they rarely deliver real SEO value. In fact, they can undermine your rankings and damage your reputation. So always choose backlinks that are relevant, trustworthy and valuable.

At TNG Agency, we help businesses build strong online authority in a sustainable way. Want to know how your backlink profile is doing?

Schedule a free SEO scan or get in touch with us.

Read more